CWEQ - Descriptive Statistics
STUDIES USING CONDITIONS OF WORK EFFECTIVENESS QUESTIONNAIRE-II (CWEQ-II)
All subscale scores range from 1-5 except ** Total CWEQ scores range from 4-20 *** Total CWEQ-II scores range from 6-30.
|
Opportunity |
Information |
Support |
Resources |
**CWEQ |
***CWEQ-II |
JAS |
ORS |
GE |
Hospital Staff Nurses |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Laschinger et al. (2001) |
3.29(.76) |
2.53(.83) |
2.55(.83) |
3.00(.71) |
11.38(2.28) |
17.35 |
2.51(.67) |
3.46(.68) |
3.05(.98) |
*Lange-Madsen (2000) |
4.26(.63) |
2.84(.87) |
3.00(.86) |
2.91(.71) |
13.00(2.18) |
19.55 |
2.87(.71) |
3.68(.73) |
3.38(.79) |
*Upenieks (2001) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Magnet Hospitals |
4.04(.82) |
3.00(.95) |
3.40(.91) |
3.02(.78) |
13.46 |
- |
- |
- |
3.54(.96) |
Non-magnet Hospitals |
3.88(.88) |
2.83(.95) |
2.85(.85) |
2.37(.78) |
11.93 |
- |
- |
- |
2.62(.89) |
*McPeak (2001) |
3.99(.76) |
3.02(.85) |
3.07(.94) |
2.89(.75) |
13.01(2.30) |
19.34 |
2.84(.82) |
3.49(.87) |
3.19(.85) |
Dale (2001) |
3.79(.75) |
2.72(.78) |
2.82(.84) |
2.91(.71) |
12.21(2.10) |
18.20 |
2.62(.79) |
3.37(.79) |
- |
Tuer-Hodes (2001) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
RNs |
3.82(.74) |
2.76(0.78) |
2.75(.83) |
2.91(.72) |
12.20(2.08) |
18.32 |
2.63(.78) |
3.49(.75) |
- |
RPNs |
3.48(.78) |
2.63(.85) |
2.83(.84) |
2.67(.68) |
11.60(2.23) |
17.29 |
2.63(.75) |
3.06(.74) |
- |
Kluska |
4.14(.69) |
2.74(.91) |
2.68(.92) |
2.91(.81) |
12.47 |
18.48(3.00) |
2.56(.83) |
3.47(.73) |
2.96(.88) |
Robertson (2003) |
3.81(.75) |
2.76(.76) |
2.62(.79) |
2.73(.76) |
11.92 |
17.70(3.13) |
2.44(.84) |
3.35(.73) |
2.82(.94) |
DeCicco (2004) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
RNs |
3.58(.83) |
3.49(1.21) |
3.25(1.02) |
2.48(.84) |
12.80 |
19.42(4.44) |
2.92(.91) |
3.73(.83) |
3.07(1.08) |
RPNs |
3.49(.84) |
3.20(.95) |
3.03(.93) |
2.46(.71) |
12.18 |
17.69(3.85) |
2.49(.74) |
3.14(.89) |
3.26(.99) |
*Manojlovich (2003) |
3.94(.79) |
3.24(.92) |
3.08(.92) |
2.91(.85) |
13.17 |
19.60(3.63) |
2.81(.89) |
3.65(.80) |
- |
Martin et al. (2005) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Time One |
3.6 |
3.2 |
3.5 |
3.0 |
13.3 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
Time Two |
3.7 |
3.2 |
3.5 |
3.0 |
13.4 |
- |
- |
- |
- |
Laschinger & Finegan (2005) |
3.97(.79) |
2.71(.85) |
2.64(.85) |
2.77(.75) |
- |
17.8(3.28) |
2.40(.86) |
3.3(.76) |
- |
Laschinger et al. (2006) |
3.98(3.41) |
2.94(.87) |
2.70(.92) |
2.88(.77) |
- |
18.43(3.41) |
2.49(.85) |
3.49(.70) |
- |
Matthews et al. (2006) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Staff Structure |
4.18(.84) |
3.03(1.05) |
2.84(.92) |
2.60(.90) |
- |
18.60(3.91) |
2.57(1.00) |
3.44(.73) |
2.71(1.04) |
Line Structure |
4.09(.82) |
2.89(.75) |
2.70(.92) |
3.12(.81) |
- |
18.80(3.91) |
2.42(.87) |
3.57(.71) |
3.11(1.03) |
Greco et al. (2006) |
3.98(.81) |
2.94(.87) |
2.70(.92) |
2.88(.77) |
- |
18.43(3.41) |
2.49(.85) |
3.49(.70) |
- |
Armstrong & Laschinger (2006) |
3.54(.83) |
2.52(1.08) |
2.51(.92) |
2.91(.83) |
- |
17.10(4.26) |
2.69(.94) |
2.93(.78) |
3.03(1.08) |
*Church (2006) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Magnet Hospitals |
4.91(.76) |
3.37(1.03) |
3.46(.92) |
3.13(.88) |
- |
20.91(4.09) |
3.21(.88) |
3.55(.85) |
3.53(.98) |
Non-magnet Hospitals |
3.88(.89) |
3.20(.92) |
3.12(.83) |
2.99(.82) |
- |
19.38(3.67) |
2.94(.85) |
3.24(.81) |
3.19(1.08) |
Young-Ritchie (2007) |
4.26(.70) |
2.76(.85) |
2.72(.91) |
2.67(.73) |
- |
18.36(3.22) |
2.69(.94) |
2.93(.78) |
3.00(1.12) |
Lucas (2007) |
4.05(.73) |
2.77(.83) |
2.71(.96) |
2.80(.76) |
- |
18.24(3.18) |
2.63(.83) |
3.30(.72) |
2.91(1.08) |
Armstrong (2007) |
4.10(.74) |
2.90(.88) |
2.84(.88) |
2.91(.76) |
- |
18.90(3.38) |
2.52(.85) |
3.64(.72) |
3.05(.96) |
Manojlovich & Laschinger (2007) |
4.01(.72) |
2.93(.92) |
2.95(.91) |
2.99(.77) |
- |
19.08(3.32) |
2.86(.82) |
3.42(.68) |
- |
*Donohue (2008) |
- |
- |
- |
- |
- |
20.04 |
3.19 |
3.53 |
- |
*McDonald, Tullai-McGuinness,
Madigan & Shively (2010) |
3.78(.87) |
2.75(.88) |
2.92(0.94) |
3.04(.72) |
- |
18.50(3.63) |
2.64(.81) |
3.37(.79) |
2.90(1.05) |
Nursing Students |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Siu (2003) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Problem-based Learning |
4.14(.50) |
3.99(.51) |
4.14(.49) |
3.72(.52) |
15.99 |
22.80(2.97) |
3.68(.66) |
3.52(.76) |
4.29(.91) |
Non problem-based Learning |
3.12(.61) |
3.33(.56) |
3.22(.51) |
3.43(.60) |
13.10 |
18.49(2.92) |
2.65(.78) |
2.84(.62) |
3.82(.59) |
Rhoades (2005) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Before Magnet Program |
3.46 |
3.12 |
3.19 |
3.74 |
- |
20.28 |
- |
- |
- |
After Magnet Program |
3.87 |
3.56 |
3.6 |
4.21 |
- |
22.84 |
- |
- |
- |
Cho (2005) |
4.27(.65) |
2.75(.77) |
2.97(.84) |
3.08(.82) |
- |
19.31(3.10) |
2.78(.76) |
3.49(.74) |
3.42(.95) |
Managers |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Laschinger et al. (2004) |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
First-line |
4.13(.64) |
3.83(.70) |
3.04(.76) |
2.43(.77) |
13.43 |
20.03(3.94) |
2.98(.77) |
3.67(.66) |
3.20(.78) |
Middle |
4.14(.67) |
4.03(.75) |
3.23(.79) |
2.57(.71) |
13.99 |
21.06(3.16) |
3.30(.81) |
3.75(.68) |
3.48(.83) |
Patrick et al. (2006) |
4.17(.67) |
4.03(.75) |
3.23(.79) |
2.57(.71) |
- |
21.05(3.16) |
3.29(.81) |
3.75(.68) |
- |
School Nurses |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
DeSisto & DeSisto (2004) |
3.86(.82) |
3.62(.82) |
3.16(1.0) |
2.78(.80) |
13.44(2.53) |
19.66 |
2.79(.79) |
3.43(.76) |
3.43(1.05) |
Nurses and Midwives |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Casey, Saunders & O’Hara (2010) |
4.12(.86) |
3.16(1.09) |
2.82(1.15) |
2.69(1.13) |
- |
19.27 |
- |
- |
- |
Nurse Practioners |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
*Stewart, McNulty, Griffin &
Fitzpatrick (2010) |
4.18(.67) |
3.62(.90) |
3.46(.82) |
3.20(.75) |
- |
25.87(1.70) |
3.41(.79) |
3.77(.97) |
- |
Psychiatric Nurses |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
*Lindsey (2006) |
4.00(.69) |
3.34(1.13) |
3.69(.85) |
3.51(.89) |
- |
21.19(3.69) |
3.00(.83) |
3.61(.73) |
3.43(.94) |
* Study completed externally to UWO empowerment program