Jamie Baxter   Jamie Baxter
Associate Professor - UWO Geography


Marking Conventions
www.uwo.ca




HOME
GEOGRAPHY
Research
Publications
Education
COURSES
GEOG 152b
GEOG 237a
GEOG 361b
GEOG 511a
Critical Appraisal
Marking
HOME | Research | Publications | Education | 152b | 237a | 361b | 511a | Marking | GEOGRAPHY
 

Marking Conventions

checkmark Good point!
checkmarkcheckmark Great point - likely because you have made a link to one of the main themes of the course!
awk Awkward wording - the meaning of the sentence is difficult to discern.
ROS Run on sentence - at least one too many phrases in the sentence.
ref. A reference to the literature is appropriate for this point.
? The point you are trying to make is not clear.
^ Insert the word or phrase above at this point.
// Start a new paragraph here - too much contained in this paragraph.
reword Although the meaning of the sentence is discernable, rewording would make the point even clearer. Often this is combined with "awk" or "NAS".
NAS Not a sentence - most likely the subject, object, or verb is missing.
# Number the pages please.
ref. list You need a reference list or bibliography - even if there is only one reference
P? Purpose unclear - What is the purpose of your paper? What is your main argument in this paper? Your purpose should be CLEARLY stated in the introductory paragraph. This might also indicate a spot where the point you are making is not consistent with the purpose of your paper.
circled word The word is misspelled, e.gs.,: use the possessive of it - its - properly; contractions like "isn't" - should NOT be used in a formal essay; use the Canadian spelling of words like favour. Here are some commonly misspelled words.
Q not equal to S Quote not equal to sentence - A direct quotation does not stand on its own. (Only rarely is this acceptable - e.g. a pithy quotation prior to the introduction of a paper - for reference, I prefer not to see these unless you directly refer to them in the introduction). A quotation should be prefaced by an introductory phrase. For example Baxter claims that, "This quotation was prefaced by the phrase for example" (author, year, page number).
crossed out word great Better word choice required - if a word is crossed out and perhaps, another suggested, it may just be a suggestion that the original word may not portray the meaning you seem to intend. In other cases it may be a grammatical error.