Table 10.1. Paradigms of the Global Political
Economy Today
|
Neo-Liberal
(Conservative) Paradigm |
Social
Democratic Paradigm |
Main Loyalty |
Business
Corporations |
The Public Good (Civil
Society) |
Economic Ethic |
Economic
Efficiency and Corporate Profits |
High Employment and Economic Equality |
Favoured Institutions |
Transnational Corporations, the IMF, the
World Bank, the World Trade Organization |
Democratically-elected legislatures,
citizen groups, labour unions, environmental organizations |
Position on Government
Intervention |
“Night
Watchman” State: Minimal government regulation of the economy; profits come
first; skepticism about ecological concerns |
Welfare State: Moderate
to high government regulation; Keynsian
interventions when needed; social equality trumps corporate profits;
ecological concerns real |
Public Services that should be
run by the State |
Police,
Armed Forces, Primary Education, basic infrastructure (though not especially
utilities) |
Police, Armed Forces,
Water, Gas, Electricity, Parks and Nature Preserves, Health Care, Education,
Infrastructure (e.g. roads), some Transportation (e.g. national airline),
some Communications (e.g. state-run television network), Post Office |
Position on International Trade and Finance |
Free trade; floating
exchange rates; disciplining of weak economies by a “free” market and stricter
controls on deficit-spending governments by refusing World Bank/IMF
assistance |
Regulated
trade: national tariffs and subsidies are acceptable; regulation or fixing of
exchange rates; more consideration to be given to developing countries which
fall behind on loan payments |